Above is demonstrated the Marcy no-mesh repair, which can be a good option in certain young thin females (link to paper).
Here we present a selection of available operations for inguinal hernia repairs. We have grouped them based on the use of mesh. In general mesh is recommended by the surgical community. However we understand how some of our patients, after having done their own research, would prefer to avoid mesh implantation. We also offer several promising non-standard mesh repairs for select patients.
Developed by Dr. Cober, the Cober Method is not a novel surgical technique, but rather it is our adaptation of utilizing the currently available techniques developed by diverse surgeons and centers who all in their own right had exceptional experience and insight. The method rests upon the following tenets of hernia surgery:
The repair of hernias is a matter of quality of life and thus must aim for cure and minimizing risk of recurrence all while having low or zero tolerance for complications or chronic pain.
Less tension leads to less chance of recurrence and lower pain.
If there is tension, it should be patched to distribute and diffuse the tension.
The importance of permant sutures is less when there is good tissue overlap.
It is preferable to avoid the use of a foreign body if tissue-techniques can result in a similarly good outcome.
The least amount of anesthesia needed to achieve a comfortable experience is ideal.
Optimal health in patients is ideal: good weight, fitness, health, and no smoking/toxic ingestions.
Open repairs under MAC anesthesia are generally preferred due to simplicity, safety, and least invasiveness.
We also offer laparoscopic TEP repairs for small, direct, and recurrent hernias from open operations; we generally prefer TEP over TAPP due to lack of peritoneal entry.
If there is an isolated femoral hernia:
Cober modification of Lockwood repair: medium-weight small mesh patch sutured to Cooper's, Inguinal, and Lacunar ligaments with permanent sutures with inner knots.
For direct and indirect hernias we have two primary goals:
Restore normal anatomy
Patch or reinforce repair
Indirect hernias: Usually sac and cord lipomas are excised to decrease pressure on internal ring.
Desarda strip +/- lateral internal ring closure with absorbable sutures, or
Primary closure with permanent sutures, two-layer, or
Lichtenstein for fatty-replaced tissue or very dilated lateral rings
Direct hernias:
Shouldice four-layer repair, or
Shouldice first two layers with absorbable vs permanent sutures + Desarda strip, or
Floor plication + Lichtenstein for fatty-replaced tissue or very large direct defects
Cober modifications of popular techniques:
Shouldice:
Cremasters spared.
Prolene used.
Desarda:
If there was a large hernia or there is not excellent tissue overlap, we utilize permanent sutures to the inguinal ligament, and intermittently at the superior suture line.
If there was a large indirect hernia, we apply lateral permanent sutures to the inguinal ligament to cover the lateral internal ring.
Lichtenstein:
If there was a large hernia (especially a direct), we may utilize a medium-weight mesh.
We place intermittent permanent sutures superiorly and especially medially.
We may trim the mesh tails based on nerve branch anatomy or with an inferior-based slit.
Permanent mesh repairs are considered the standard by most in the surgical community. Several hernia specialists however believe that mesh is overutilized in most hernias. In most studies, the use of mesh did not result in a statistically significant increase in chronic pain or complications. The use of mesh however was correlated with a lower recurrence rate (about 0.5-5%). There are, of note, rare cases of well-documented mesh-related illness due to uncommon immune reactions.
Open repair with mesh (Lichtenstein)
The worldwide standard with anterior mesh placement.
+ Flexible anesthesia: local, twilight/MAC, or general
+ Defects can be closed directly prior to mesh placement (theoretically lower recurrence and improved function)
+ Lightweight mesh often adequate
+ Exceedingly rare (0%) risk of major complications
+ Very low recurrence rate: 0.5-2%
- Slightly increased pain during first 3 days as compared to laparoscopic
- Slightly higher rate of chronic pain: 0.5-5%
Laparoscopic repair with mesh (TEP)
Posterior mesh placement and technically challenging for large hernias. We only offer TEPs for small hernias and often use progrip mesh.
+ Slightly less pain post-operatively
+ Routine coverage of the femoral space
+ No long peritoneal suture line as in TAPP
+ Low recurrence rate: 1-5%
+ Bilateral hernias can be done at the same time
- Requires general anesthesia although sometimes this may be done with an LMA as opposed to endotracheal tube
- We do not close defects with this technique though this has been described
- Slightly higher rate of complications such as hematomas and major vascular injury
- Slightly higher rate of chronic pain: 0.5-5%
Robotic repair with mesh (rTAPP)
The emerging procedure of choice for most US surgeons due to improved ergonomics and a wide mesh overlap. We currently do not offer rTAPP, however we refer to local experts in this technique, which is suitable for large hernias and obese patients.
+ Less pain post-operatively
+ Routine coverage of the femoral space
+ Very low recurrence rate: 0.5-1%
+ Very low chronic pain rate: 0.5-2%
+ Bilateral hernias can be done at the same time
- Intraperitoneal entry and suture line
- Requires general endotracheal anesthesia
- We do not close defects with this technique though this has been described
- Slightly higher rate of complications such as hematomas, major vascular injury, and small bowel obstruction
Open preperitoneal mesh
Posterior mesh placement; we do not offer this technique and are unaware of any local surgeons who perform it.
+ Slightly less pain post-operatively
+ Seems comparable to other standard mesh repairs in terms of recurrence and chronic pain rates
- Theoretical concerns with lack of mesh fixation and wide overlap
- Theoretical concern of additional fascial entry site as a future potential hernia site
Many studies demonstrate that non-mesh repairs are comparable to mesh repairs. Therefore several hernia specialists believe that non-mesh repairs are equivalent when performed by experts (recurrence rates of 3-6%). Most agree that these repairs should either not be used or used with caution in patients with risk factors for recurrence (e.g. recurrent hernias, obesity, and smoking).
Shouldice
This appears to be the best refinement of the classic Bassini tissue repair. As with many non-Shouldice Hospital surgeons, we modify this procedure and typically reserve it for isolated direct hernias (we do not divide the cremasters and use prolene suture).
+ Flexible anesthesia: local, twilight/MAC, or general
+ Ideal for closure of the direct defect
+ Exceedingly rare (0%) risk of major complications
+ Low recurrence rate: 1-6%
+ Low chronic pain rate: 0.5-5%
- Not well studied with absorbable suture
- Slightly increased pain during the first week as compared to mesh
- Large dissection field even for small indirect hernias
Desarda
There is a growing body of evidence supporting this lower-tension tissue-based repair. We modify this technique to utilize permanent sutures as originally described and couple it with defect closure and utilize lateral sutures for indirect defects.
+ Flexible anesthesia: local, twilight/MAC, or general
+ Less tension thus slightly less pain as compared to the Shouldice repair
+ Exceedingly rare (0%) risk of major complications
+ Low chronic pain rate: 0.5-5%
- Slightly higher recurrence rate with absorbable sutures: 5-6% vs 1-6%
- Slightly increased pain during the first week as compared to mesh
- Theoretical concern with flap degradation over decades
These repairs are not as well studied but show promise in preliminary research. Selection of one of these procedures requires a pre-operative ultrasound and more in-depth analysis prior to operation to assess for suitability. We expect recurrence rates to be consistent with non-mesh repairs, e.g. 3-6%. For these repairs we suggest local or light MAC anesthesia so the patient can cough after the repair to ensure stability.
Kang repair
This appears to be a physiologically and anatomically sound repair which we expect to have comparably high success rates to the Shouldice repair but is more uniquely tailored to the actual hernia defect. This repair is currently as of 2026 only offered at the Gibbeum Hospital in Seoul. We expect this to become a standard option once it is replicated in studies by other surgeons and institutions.
Robotic absorbable mesh (rTAPPa)
There is preliminary data showing low and acceptable recurrence rates for defect closure and absorbable mesh placement. We currently do not offer this technique.
Open high ligation
This is an application of the high ligation procedure to patients with small indirect inguinal hernias. This procedure does not require general endotracheal anesthesia. This approach may be coupled with Marcy or Lytle sutures to tighten the internal ring. Furthermore a light-weight absorbable mesh such as Phasix or DuraSorb can be utilized to buttress the repair.
Laparoscopic/robotic high ligation
For appropriately selected patients, this may be the least invasive procedure available in terms of pain and tissue dissection. This procedure, though requiring general endotracheal anesthesia, is the quickest procedure resulting in the least amount of time under anesthesia. This repair is adapted from pediatric hernia repairs for adults with similar hernia pathophysiology. Cord lipomas and direct hernias are unable to be addressed with this procedure, therefore we currently do not offer this. We currently do not offer this technique however we can refer to national experts in this technique.
Small, asymptomatic hernia → No surgery may be needed at this time ("watchful waiting")
Female → Consider Laparoscopic TEP or no-mesh repair under MAC anesthesia and rule-out femoral hernia
Bilateral hernia (left and right) → Laparoscopic TEP or robotic TAPP if large
Obesity / BMI > 40 (see calculator on page) → Robotic TAPP but ideally lose weight
Recurrent hernia → Approach the hernia from a different approach as to what was done initially
Previous lower abdominal surgery (e.g. prostatectomy) or pelvic radiation → Desarda / Lichtenstein
Age less than 40 → Consider Desarda / Shouldice / Laparoscopic High Ligation
Age greater than 70 → Lichtenstein
Here we discuss the success rate of inguinal hernia surgery. Generally these days, recurrence rates are quite low, and so our goal is to, while maintaining low recurrence rates, to refine our surgical outcomes and decrease post-op pain, minimize recovery, and lower the rate of chronic pain.
Small internal ring hernia with preperitoneal fat in a young thin female with intact floor anatomy; a Marcy repair with absorbable suture and DuraSorb (absorbable mesh) buttress was utilized here.
Femoral hernia on the left side (patient's head towards the top of image) demonstrating incarcerated preperitoneal fat.
Femoral hernia on the left side (patient's head towards the top of image) repaired with custom medium-weight prolene mesh. Lockwood repair.
Video from Dr. Swarmy demonstrating Lichtenstein technique.
This is an excellent video with Dr. Desarda demonstrating his technique on a direct inguinal hernia.
This is a video demonstrating the Shouldice technique, the quality is low; there is a better quality video with Dr. Reinhorn that requires a subscription here.
This is one of the best, if not the best, video I have seen online demonstrating the TEP technique. Dr. Swamy uses diathermy dissection to keep things relatively bloodless.
Dr. Liu demonstrating a robotic TAPP inguinal hernia repair.