We are blessed with a wealth of research and published experience with hernia surgery. Even common and old operations continue to be further studied and refined world-wide.
Many studies and articles do have some limitations though including inconsistency in techniques and lack of important technical details in the manuscripts.
We rarely take one study in isolation but look at patterns that emerge from multiple studies.
The history of inguinal hernia surgery spans millenia and includes some amazing techniques developed by anatomists and surgeons -- some of which we are still further refining today.
This review of data suggest that after open inguinal hernia repairs, there is a higher post-op incidence of femoral hernias -- most of these occurred within a year suggesting they were missed at time of diagnosis. Combining this data with other data suggests that women might have an increase in lifetime risk of femoral hernia from 1% to 3-5% after open inguinal hernia repair, and men from 0.1% to 0.5%. It is conceivable that tissue repairs might increase these odds slightly due to tension on the inguinal ligament.
Summary: It appears the Shouldice procedure is best performed at the Shouldice Hospital consistently. Also it appears to have recurrence rates very similar if not quite as low as mesh repairs. My suggestion is that it is an excellent technique and can be tailored to the hernia anatomy. For example, it seems overly invasive for an isolated small indirect hernia. It appears that commonly performed modifications must be carefully considered based on the particular hernia anatomy (e.g. dividing the cremasters may be essential to snug the new internal ring in the case of a laterally dilated internal ring).
This is a landmark paper from Shouldice surgeons from 2006. Their recurrence rate is 1% and they describe their technique.
This is a paper from 1995 from the UK with 53 repairs with a two-layer transversalis fascia repair vs 42 repairs with a four-layer Shouldice repair. They found a 3 year recurrence of 4% in the two-layer group vs 5% in the four-layer group. This paper describes a technique of nylon, and locking the stitch after the first layer. They do not describe treatment of the cremasters and lateralization of the cord. Recall that nylon is thought to lose strength as the years pass and hernias may recur years and decades later. Of note, this paper discusses how double-breasting may form a superior scar plate to simple "plication" of the floor.
I suggest this is a useful paper but am hesitant to apply it with concerns in the cases of patulous lateral internal rings or large direct hernias. I do suspect this is useful in the case of direct hernias over which we will patch a mesh or a Desarda strip.
This is a 1992 paper documenting VA experience of doing a two-layer Shouldice with a 1.2% recurrence rate in about a four-year follow-up.
This paper included Shouldice surgeons and is from 2024. At 16 months of follow-up a 1.6% recurrence rate was noted with no difference between stainless-steel and polypropylene (2-0 or 0). Most surgeons think that prolene is probably equivalent to stainless-steel in terms of long-term results, so this is a welcome early results paper.
This is a Cochrane review from 2012 suggesting that Shouldice is the best non-mesh technique and that mesh does lower the recurrence rate. Recurrence rates for Shouldice were 3.6-4.4%, other non-mesh techniques 6.9%, and mesh 0.8%.
Suggests recurrence is similar but possibly higher chronic pain with Shouldice repair.
This is a meta-analysis and it found Lichtenstein recurrence rate to be 0.9% and the Shouldice rate to be 4.2%.
This is a meta-analysis suggesting Shouldice and Desarda have comparable outcomes.
Summary: The Desarda technique now has growing evidence showing that it is reproducible and comparable to mesh repairs. It is technically simpler and requires less dissection and suturing than a Shouldice repair. My question with it stems with its treatment of the laterally dilated internal ring. In such cases I question if adding a Lytle's repair and lateral sutures would address this area. Furthermore, regarding the use of absorbable sutures, I would like to see longer follow-up as, unlike the mesh in the Lichtenstein-Amid repair, the strip really has minimal overlap over strong tissue in this repair.
This is a 2021 paper from Poland showing a 1.5% recurrence rate of Desarda technique at 15 years. They excluded cases where the external oblique aponeurosis seemed thin or to have separated fibers. 2-0 surgipro utilized, and a 2-2.5 cm strip used.
Here Dr. Desarda published his data worldwide in 2002 demonstrating a 1.25% recurrence rate at 10 years.
Suggetive of equivalent outcomes between Lichtenstein (2.6% recurrence) and Desarda (4.2% recurrence) and perhaps a better pain profile with Desarda.
This is a 2015 study from Egypt. 2-0 prolene used for Desarda (exclusion of weak, stretched, or thin EOA); prolene mesh, 6x11cm, and 2-0 prolene was used for Lichtenstein. Recurrence at the deep internal ring in Desarda group, and at pubic tubercle in mesh group. No significant differences were found. 168 patients compared, recurrence rates of 1.2% for Desarda and Lichtenstein at 2 years of follow-up.
This 2024 meta-analysis showed no difference between Desarda and Lichtenstein in terms of recurrence (1.4% vs 2.1%) but did seem to decrease chronic pain.
A 2019 study from Bangledesh; nylon or prolene utilized; 1 year follow-up showed no recurrences.
Suggests the Desarda technique is an excellent option in potentially contaminated fields.
A 2008 report from Dr. Desarda with 256 hernias with a mean follow-up of 24 months using the Desarda technique with no. 1 PDS that showed no recurrences. Strip 1.5-2 cm.
A 2026 study from India supporting the use of PDS in the repair. This study, however, only has a 6 month follow-up. Likely longer (>1 year) follow-up is needed, and ideally even longer follow-up.
Summary: There is a lot to be studied with different non-mesh techniques. It seems that the US surgical community has grown fatigued by all the confusion in the literature and now settles on modern mesh-based techniques due to their reproducibility and good results.
The Coskun repair -- a fascia transversalis repair. At an average of 3 years of follow-up, no recurrences were found. This appears to me be a two-layer corrupted Bassini (see letter from Dr. Amid). Regardless, the results are interesting.
A 2015 report from Turkey using retrospective analaysis. The average follow-up was about 3 years. Recurrence rates were 3.1% for Coskun and 2.9% for Lichtenstein. Continuous sutures are utilized. The first layer is a plication of the transversalis fasica, and the second layer is an approximation of the conjoint tnedon and inguinal ligament. Suture type is not mentioned.
A 1971 article that describes how division of the cremasters is essential to fully visualize the inner aspect of the internal hernia ring and
A 2022 report from Dr. Chung in Korea. I would love to see this further described -- it is modification of a Marcy/Lytle internal ring closure.
2012 study from Japan with 3 year follow-up did not show any recurrences in either Marcy of PHS repairs of indirect inguinal hernias. This adds evidence that a Marcy repair is sufficient for an isolated indirect hernia.
This is a 2018 Cochrane review suggesting that mesh likely reduces hernia recurrence (2% vs 4%) without an increase in significant complications.
This is a 2023 Cochrane review explaining there is a lack of good evidence to guide in this situation. Most hernia surgeons would likely suggest to utilize a non-mesh or absorbable mesh technique in the case where there is potential for contamination.
2009 paper from Dr. Muschaweck. This technique was utilized for a focal weakness in the inguinal floor and 2-0 prolene was used to do a double-breasting of the transversalis fascia just in the isolated area of weakness. The second layer was brought to the inguinal ligament and the rectus was lateralized to the inguinal ligament. There is no long-term data provided. I would be very interested in further study comparing against a physical therapy regimen.
2013 paper from the USA comparing the Minimal Repair technique to a modified Bassini. Results showed a faster return to sports in the Minimal Repair group. There was an approximately 14% recurrence of symptoms with a follow-up of about 2 years.
This is an interesting description of the Guarnieri technique developed on 1988 which can be used with or without mesh. It does appear complicated.
This is a low powered 2025 study (about 10 cases in each arm) with one year of follow-up showing no recurrence. 2-0 prolene used in the modified Desarda technique. This modification was done to reduce the "lateral weakness" of the Desarda. But it is unclear to me if the closure of the old internal ring was left covered only with internal oblique and not covered with the Desarda strip.
This is a 2010 article from Pakistan with a recurrence of 1.85% at 5 years of follow-up. Transversalis fascia is plicated with 2-0 prolene to the inguinal ligament. It is not explicitly stated which suture is used to suture the EOA and some of the specifics are not detailed. I would think that the external oblique would be under tension and want to pull away from the inguinal ligament without the relaxing incision as seen in the Desarda technique. This is reminiscent of the Halsted technique.
Description of Dr. Ferguson's treatment of the internal ring for indirect hernias and bringing the superior aspect of the ring and muscle arch down to the inguinal ligament over the cord. Perhaps like a "lateral" Bassini.
1983 study of McVay operation found a recurrence of 20.7% after 15 years for pure indirect hernias and 7.5% after 15 years for pure direct hernias. Of note, 50% of recurrences from indirect hernias were direct. This could potentially be to weakening of the tensioned direct space vs disruption of the floor during dissection and repair.
Modern Lichtenstein tension-free mesh repair: step-by-step operative technique
Trabucco’s ‘suture-less tension-free’ hernia repair: technique, local anesthesia and results
Inguinal hernia repair with the trabucco technique: A multicenter analysis with 5-year follow-up
Sutureless Repair for Open Treatment of Inguinal Hernia: Three Techniques in Comparison
2026 study demonstrating short-term safety with respect to pain of partial closure of the internal ring during rTAPP posterior approach. This is a helpful step towards better understanding the potential of the posterior approach.
2004 landmark paper demonstrating laparoscopic vs open results -- notice how with high skill and experience, there was no difference in recurrence rates (about 4-5%).
Excerpt 1989: PTFE had the best handling characteristics, but is expensive, and increased wound sepsis attended its use. Polybutester had significantly better handling characteristics, and is an attractive alternative to nylon for hernia repair.
What are the indications for heavy vs medium vs lightweight mesh in hernia repair?
Mesh Weight in Reoperation for Recurrence After Laparoscopic Inguinal Hernia Repair
Lightweight versus heavyweight mesh in laparoscopic inguinal hernia repair: a meta-analysis
Lightweight versus heavyweight in inguinal hernia repair: a meta-analysis